Race for Nebraska’s top election official features fights over limiting mail voting, banning early voting

This year’s race for Nebraska secretary of state has featured drama from the get-go, starting with the upset of incumbent Republican Secretary of State Bob Evnen in the May primary.

This story is made possible through a partnership between Flatwater Free Press and Votebeat, a nonprofit news organization covering local election administration and voting access.

The race for Nebraska secretary of state is drawing attention to the Republican frontrunner, Scott Petersen, who questions the integrity of the state’s election systems, calls for strictly limiting voting by mail and says he will proudly wear the label of one of the most far-right conservative top election officials in the country if elected.

The three other candidates facing Petersen echo one another in giving him another label: Dangerous.

“I do think it’s dangerous if we get somebody in charge of our elections that is so upfront about their partisanship,” said Sarah Slattery, the Democrat in the race.

The race for Nebraska secretary of state typically doesn’t draw much attention. In fact, it has been downright monotonous in its predictability; Republicans have held the office for 85 years — since before the U.S. entered World War II.

But this year’s race has featured drama from the get-go, starting with Petersen’s upset of incumbent Republican Secretary of State Bob Evnen in the May primary. Petersen won with nearly 55% of the vote in a primary that drew fewer than one in three registered voters to the polls. He did it on a platform of questioning the security of the machines that count votes in Nebraska and vilifying Evnen’s support of that system.

Nebraska residents vote by marking paper ballots, and those ballots then are run through an optical scanner that tabulates them. Petersen questions whether those machines can be hacked — an allegation that appealed to those among the conservative base who believe the 2020 presidential election was corrupted by fraud. Evnen has maintained that the machines are never connected to the internet and therefore aren’t open to remote hacking.

Petersen, who ran for Douglas County clerk in 2020, losing to Democrat Daniel Esch, has been heavily involved in Nebraska Republican politics for decades. He previously served as a Douglas County GOP chairman and a political consultant who has run the campaigns of several state lawmakers, among others.

He has been a guest on the podcasts of those who promote debunked claims of fraud in the 2020 election, including Steve Bannon, a conservative pundit and former adviser to President Donald Trump. 

Scott Petersen, a Republican who is running for Nebraska secretary of state. Courtesy photo

Since advancing to the general race, where he’ll have to appeal to a more diverse electorate, Petersen has softened his tone — a bit. He insists he’s not an election denier and says he does not believe Nebraska suffers from election fraud. But when asked if he believes the 2020 election was stolen from Trump, he wavers.

“I think there’s a lot there,” he said while acknowledging that there’s not enough evidence “right now” to prove it. “But there’s enough there that we should absolutely ask those questions and have better systems for sure.”

Petersen’s preference would be to limit mail voting. Since 1999, Nebraska has allowed no-excuse absentee voting; all a voter has to do is request a mail ballot. Petersen wants to limit that to military members and those physically unable to get to a polling place.

He also would revamp the system that allows counties with fewer than 10,000 residents to hold all-mail elections, which 11 counties in Nebraska currently do. Petersen said residents he has spoken with in those counties have complained that they can’t go to their polling place to vote on Election Day.

“If you’re going to cheat, mail-in balloting is one of the places that you can tamper with elections,” he said.

Sarah Slattery is a Democrat running for Nebraska secretary of state. Courtesy photo

He wants to do away with in-person early voting altogether and allow hand-counting of ballots in contested races. Studies show that hand counting is both far more time consuming and less accurate than paper ballots counted with optical scanners. 

Asked what his priority would be immediately upon taking office, Petersen said he would work to make Nebraska’s voting system transparent, but when asked what that would entail, he simply said he had a team working with lawmakers to figure that out.

Former state Sen. Bob Krist, who is running as the America First Party candidate, made his concern about Petersen clear.

“Scott Petersen is a MAGA guy. He said it from the very beginning,” Krist said. “He’s going to make sure that we go back to the days of Jim Crow and limit votes rather than expanding the right to vote.”

Former Nebraska Secretary of State John Gale, a Republican, said attempts by Trump to exert control over elections have muddied the waters on where that authority lies.

Bob Krist, the America First Party candidate for Nebraska secretary of state. Courtesy photo

“The truth of the matter is that, under the Constitution, the president has no election authority,” Gale said.

Contrary to fears that election security has degraded in recent years, Gale noted, efforts were made to improve the reliability of voting equipment following the 2000 presidential election. That election saw the U.S. Supreme Court decide in favor of Republican George W. Bush over Democrat Al Gore following machine voting abnormalities in Florida. The decision awarded Bush fewer than 550 votes in that state, giving him 271 electoral votes to Gore’s 267, even though Gore won the national popular vote.

The passage of the 2002 Help America Vote Act largely eliminated accuracy concerns of the previous decades, Gale said, by providing money and oversight to the states for updated election equipment.

“The nature of the equipment we use today is just astonishing, how fast and accurate it is,” he said. “There isn’t any state that isn’t subject to much more rigorous standards for accuracy of voting and for accuracy of counting.”

Paul Rumbaugh is the Nebraska Working People Party candidate for Nebraska secretary of state. Courtesy photo

Working People Party candidate Paul Rumbaugh accused Petersen of taking orders from Republican Party leadership to undermine voting.

“He is dangerous to Nebraska,” Rumbaugh said. “Scott is going in lockstep with the GOP leadership and will until Nebraska loses its autonomy.”

Petersen would join a handful of top election officials across the country who have called for limits in voting, including current Wyoming Secretary of State Chuck Gray, former Republican Kentucky Secretary of State Trey Grayson said. A former president of the National Association of Secretaries of State, Grayson said he was disappointed when Evnen lost the primary earlier this year.

“One thing to keep in mind is that legislators are the ones that make policy. So even if Petersen wants to make wholesale changes to election policy, the Legislature ultimately will be the ones making that decision,” Grayson said. “Also, local election administrators in many states are able to weigh in — and sometimes successfully.”

Petersen acknowledged as much and said he plans to work with lawmakers to make changes. With half the Nebraska legislative seats up for election this year, it remains to be seen whether he would have the support needed to do so.

By Margery Beck

Margery Beck has covered Nebraska elections, politics and government for nearly 30 years, including 28 years with The Associated Press. Before joining the AP in 1998, she was a reporter, columnist and editorial writer at the Fremont Tribune in Fremont, Nebraska. She was a reporter and columnist from 1992-97 at The Bolivar Commercial in Cleveland, Mississippi, where she studied political science at Delta State University.

7 Comments

Ah yes, let’s see how many people we can find who will blame this on Trump, then publish their entirely unwanted opinions as if it were news.

Let’s not tell anyone that Evnen lost because he never bothered to do his job, didn’t respond when individual voters contacted him about their concerns, and spent all his time telling the media that the status quo was just fine the way it is.

““He is dangerous to Nebraska,” Rumbaugh said. ”

This is what is truly disgusting nowadays about politics, and FFP feeds them.

It’s not enough to say that you disagree and why; by demonizing your opponents– they’re “dangerous”, they’re “evil”, they’re “fascists”, et al.–you don’t have to actually promote, substantiate, and contrast your views with your opponents.

It’s perverse and FFP provides them a platform.

Let’s try better.

“He [Peterson] has been a guest on the podcasts of those who promote debunked claims of fraud in the 2020 election, including Steve Bannon, a conservative pundit and former adviser to President Donald Trump. ”

Not sure if that’s relevant information, but okay…

But notice what FFP/Votebeat does not say about Working People Party candidate Paul Rumbaugh: there’s no mention about the mysterious founding and funding for the Nebraska Working People party–the NWPP refuses to disclose their donors. And most of the NWPP officers have resigned. Why isn’t that information mentioned?

Same for Bob Krist and his mysterious America First “party”. Why no mention of the shady founding and funding of the AFP?

Enough of calling elections fake or fraudulent without any proof. It’s way past time we moved out of seeing a boogey man in everything to undermine institutions that for the most part work I hope the public is as sick of these witch-hunts as I am and will look at who is keeping them going. This mind set is the same that got women killed in Salem for allegedly being witches. Happy Halloween and vote with confidence there is no fraud. Good article Beck for shining the light.

“Enough of calling elections fake or fraudulent without any proof.”

Agreed.

Hakeem Jeffries, Feb. 2018:

‘“The more we learn about 2016 election the more ILLEGITIMATE it becomes. America deserves to know whether we have a FAKE President in the Oval Office.”

So, we have a NE Sec’y of State candidate who was on some election denier’s podcast years ago, and then we have Hakeem Jeffries, the well-know election denier and current US House Minority Leader who visited Nebraska this month to stump for a Democrat.

Yes, enough of Democrats calling elections fake or fraudulent without any proof. But if you only read FFP, you’d never know of them.

I haven’t been afraid of scary things made up by others to manipulate me since I was 3 years old. And then I just turned and face the wall like my dad suggested and went to sleep peacefully.
An entire cult of people who believe the boogeyman of election fraud exists, despite never actually seeing one or seeing an effect on their own lives, has been created, and now has elected someone with the same irrational fears.
With regard to Evnen, he of course was a fool who literally sued himself for being incompetent on multiple occasions in connection with the cannabis measure, but I have always found his office to be very responsive to my concerns, the most recent one being the actual existence of a list that Trump says exists that will control who is able to vote.

Leave a Reply